Post Time: 2025-07-26
The quest for sweetness without the downsides of sugar has led to a surge in popularity for sugar substitutes. But navigating this world of artificial sweeteners and natural alternatives can be confusing. Luckily, experts like Dr. Steven Gundry and Jessie Inchauspé, aka the Glucose Goddess, have weighed in, offering insights into which "fake" sugars might be the best choices for our health. This article will dive into their recommendations, exploring the benefits, drawbacks, and scientific basis behind these alternatives, providing you with a clear guide to making informed decisions.
The Problem with Traditional Sugar:
Before delving into alternatives, it's important to understand why reducing sugar intake is beneficial. Consuming excessive amounts of sugar has been linked to numerous health issues including:
- Insulin Resistance: Leading to type 2 diabetes and metabolic syndrome.
- Weight Gain: Sugar provides empty calories that can contribute to excess weight and obesity.
- Inflammation: Chronic inflammation has been linked to various diseases.
- Energy Crashes: Rapid spikes and drops in blood sugar levels can leave you feeling fatigued.
- Gut Microbiome Disruption: Can negatively impact the balance of good bacteria in your gut.
Therefore, understanding that the problem is real is the first step into reducing sugar intake.
The Gundry and Glucose Goddess Approach to "Fake" Sugars
Both Dr. Gundry, a renowned heart surgeon and author of "The Plant Paradox," and Jessie Inchauspé (The Glucose Goddess), a biochemist and author of "Glucose Revolution," advocate for mindful consumption of sugar and have explored the use of low-glycemic sweeteners as potential alternatives. Although there may be some discrepancies between their opinions, they do converge on their recommendations on which one are beneficial, which ones to watch out for. Let's break down their take on some of the most talked-about sweeteners.
1. Stevia:
- What It Is: Stevia is a natural sweetener derived from the leaves of the Stevia rebaudiana plant. It contains steviol glycosides, which are intensely sweet but have negligible calories and virtually no effect on blood glucose.
- Dr. Gundry's Take: He generally considers stevia a safe option, particularly because it's a plant-based alternative and doesn't have the potential downsides of artificial sweeteners, he doesn't think it is the best choice though.
- Glucose Goddess' Take: The Glucose Goddess highlights that stevia has no impact on blood sugar. This is ideal when trying to reduce blood glucose spikes and avoid the energy crashes associated with sugar consumption.
- Scientific Data: Studies have shown that stevia consumption doesn't lead to significant increases in blood sugar or insulin levels, it does show though that there might be negative impacts on gut microbiome. However more research is needed to understand the long term impacts.
| Feature | Stevia |
|---|---|
| Origin | Natural, Plant-based |
| Calories | Negligible |
| Blood Sugar Impact | None |
| Flavor | Can have aftertaste |
2. Monk Fruit (Luo Han Guo):
- What It Is: Monk fruit, or Luo Han Guo, is another natural, zero-calorie sweetener extracted from a fruit native to Southeast Asia. It's primarily comprised of compounds called mogrosides, which are responsible for its sweetness.
- Dr. Gundry's Take: He recommends it as a solid natural alternative to sugar that is good for overall health.
- Glucose Goddess' Take: She also likes monk fruit as a sugar substitute due to its lack of impact on blood glucose. It's generally seen as a safer option, because some studies have demonstrated its benefits.
- Scientific Data: Scientific research supports its minimal effect on blood glucose levels. Additionally, some studies show mogrosides might have antioxidant and anti-inflammatory properties, which offer added potential health benefits. However, further research is needed to confirm these effects.
| Feature | Monk Fruit |
|---|---|
| Origin | Natural, Fruit-based |
| Calories | Negligible |
| Blood Sugar Impact | None |
| Flavor | Sweet, No aftertaste |
3. Erythritol:
- What It Is: Erythritol is a sugar alcohol (a type of carbohydrate) that is found naturally in some fruits. It has about 70% of the sweetness of sugar but has negligible calories and does not significantly impact blood sugar levels.
- Dr. Gundry's Take: He finds it is another one of the good options when talking about sweeteners.
- Glucose Goddess' Take: She often discusses that its blood sugar impact is none which is aligned with the Gundry philosophy.
- Scientific Data: Numerous studies indicate that erythritol is generally well-tolerated, with most of it being excreted through urine. It has minimal impact on blood sugar or insulin, making it a favorable option for those monitoring their glucose levels. However, consuming high doses of erythritol might cause some digestive discomfort.
- Note: Combining Erythritol with other sweeteners, like Stevia, can cause it to crystalize, which is why sometimes is not a popular choice to use in recipes that need the perfect texture.
| Feature | Erythritol |
|---|---|
| Origin | Natural, in fruits, fermented |
| Calories | Negligible |
| Blood Sugar Impact | None |
| Flavor | Sweet, can be a cooling effect |
Sweeteners to Be Cautious About:
While natural alternatives like Stevia, Monk Fruit, and Erythritol generally receive a thumbs-up from experts, other sweeteners, both artificial and natural, come with more caveats. Here’s a brief overview:
Artificial Sweeteners (Aspartame, Sucralose, Saccharin):
- What They Are: These are lab-made substances that are hundreds of times sweeter than sugar. They offer no calories but are often surrounded by health concerns.
- Dr. Gundry's Take: He generally advises avoiding these, mainly due to their potential negative effects on the gut microbiome, as research suggests these disrupt the balance of beneficial gut bacteria.
- Glucose Goddess' Take: She is against these as well, citing similar issues as Dr. Gundry. She recommends to try not to trick the body, because the lack of sugar intake can cause it to create an overcompensation response.
- Scientific Data: There is much debate regarding the safety of artificial sweeteners. While some studies show they are safe for consumption, others suggest there might be negative impacts on the gut health, metabolism, and even insulin response. Thus, there is a need for more research on long term effects.
Agave Nectar:
- What It Is: Often marketed as a healthier alternative to sugar, agave nectar is derived from the agave plant. It is extremely high in fructose.
- Dr. Gundry's Take: He recommends avoiding agave. Due to its high fructose content, this causes liver issues and doesn't have a positive impact in the human body.
- Glucose Goddess' Take: Her take aligns with Dr. Gundry, mainly because a higher amount of fructose impacts the liver more than a higher amount of glucose.
- Scientific Data: Agave’s high fructose content has been linked to similar metabolic problems as sugar, and its blood glucose response is not good.
Key Takeaways and Practical Tips:
- Prioritize Natural, Low-Glycemic Sweeteners: When choosing a sweetener, focus on options like Stevia, Monk Fruit, and Erythritol. They have the least impact on blood sugar levels, and are mostly considered safe.
- Read Labels Carefully: Pay attention to ingredient lists and be cautious of products that contain a blend of different sweeteners. Watch out for products that use many different kinds of artificial sweeteners.
- Reduce overall consumption of sweeteners: If you are used to consume a high intake of sweets, your palate might be too sensitive to them. The best method is always reduce your overall intake, rather than substituting the sweetener. This means that over time, the less you eat sweets, the less you crave them.
- Experiment with Portion Sizes: Even with these safer sweeteners, moderation is key. Start with small amounts and see how your body reacts. Always keep in mind that overeating anything is bad.
- Whole Food Focus: Rather than looking for alternative ways to make sweet stuff, try and focus on eating whole food. Most of the time, your sweet cravings go away once you prioritize a high-quality intake of diverse foods.
- Consider the Source: Natural sweeteners often are not available in raw formats, so always look for organic and good-quality providers that take care of their products.
Dr. Gundry and the Glucose Goddess' perspectives provide valuable insights for navigating the world of "fake" sugars. While complete elimination of sweetness from our lives might not be realistic or enjoyable for everyone, choosing the right sweeteners can make a significant difference. By prioritizing natural, low-glycemic options, reading labels carefully, and always staying curious with research, we can make informed decisions that support overall health and well-being. Remember, reducing your overall intake is the first step to healthier habits.
blood sugar 101 after waking up 120 after meal blood sugar 155 blood sugar fasting